Feedback

Change fatigue in HE: keeping trust when change isn't a choice

18 November 2026      Emma Walton-Pond, Communications Officer

Change has become a constant across higher education. Financial pressures, restructures, evolving technologies and shifting institutional priorities mean university employees are being asked to adapt repeatedly, often while managing already demanding workloads.

AHEP's Staying resilient through repeated change event on 26 November offers a timely opportunity to reflect on how this is affecting staff across the sector.

But perhaps the most important question for university HR teams is not whether employees are resilient enough to manage chang, but whether institutions are doing enough to make change manageable in the first place.

When change becomes another source of pressure

Change is not inherently negative. Universities need to evolve, modernise and respond to new challenges. New structures, systems and ways of working can improve efficiency, collaboration and the employee experience. But even necessary change can create uncertainty.

Restructures disrupt established relationships, alter responsibilities and sometimes leave remaining employees absorbing additional work. Meanwhile, digital transformation and AI adoption introduce new expectations around skills, processes and productivity.

The challenge is not simply that employees are experiencing change. It is that repeated change, without sufficient support, clarity or involvement, can gradually undermine confidence, engagement and wellbeing.

What the HE employee experience data tells us

Successful organisational change depends on more than the decisions leaders make. Employees also need to understand where their institution is heading, why changes are necessary and how they will be affected.

Yet People Insight's latest HE staff survey benchmark data suggests there is considerable room for improvement.

Only 54% of HE employees say senior leaders provide a clear vision of their institution's direction, compared with 63% across all sectors.

Just 53% feel their opinion is sought on decisions affecting their work, nine percentage points below the wider benchmark.

Communication is another concern. Only 45% say people communicate openly regardless of position or level, compared with 56% across all sectors.

Meanwhile, just 41% believe action will be taken following their employee survey, compared with 51% across all sectors.

These findings do not measure change fatigue directly, but they highlight organisational conditions that can influence how employees experience it.

When people lack clarity about direction, feel excluded from decisions or doubt that their feedback will lead to action, even necessary changes can become harder to navigate.

Change is not experienced equally

One of the challenges facing universities is that change affects different employee groups in different ways.

Academic colleagues may be navigating changing teaching demands, research funding and departmental structures. Research staff may face uncertainty around contracts and career development.

Professional services teams are often responsible for implementing new processes and systems while maintaining essential services. Technicians, operational colleagues and student-facing teams may experience another set of pressures entirely.

People Insight's HE data illustrates why these distinctions matter. Only 50% of academic staff report a positive work-life balance, compared with 71% of professional services staff.

There are also differences in employee voice. Just 32% of academic staff believe action will follow their employee survey, compared with 37% of professional services staff.

These differences reinforce the importance of listening by staff group, department, career stage and local context. An institution-wide average cannot tell the whole story.

Resilience cannot be the whole answer

Resilience matters, particularly in complex and changing environments.

But there is a risk that encouraging employees to become more resilient places too much responsibility for managing change on the people experiencing it.

Workshops, wellbeing resources and resilience training can provide valuable support. However, they cannot compensate indefinitely for excessive workloads, unclear communication, insufficient resources or repeated changes introduced without meaningful consultation.

The goal should not be to help employees tolerate increasingly difficult working conditions. It should be to create conditions that make change more sustainable.

That requires universities to examine not only how staff respond to change, but how change itself is designed, communicated and implemented.

Why employee voice matters during change

Employee listening is particularly valuable when institutions are navigating uncertainty.

Rather than waiting until a restructure or transformation is complete, universities can use regular listening to understand how change is being experienced as it happens.

Important questions include:

●      Do employees understand why changes are happening?

●      Are workloads and responsibilities reviewed as structures change?

●      Do staff feel involved in decisions affecting their work?

●      Are managers equipped to communicate change and support their teams?

●      Do employees feel comfortable raising concerns or suggesting improvements?

●      Are previous changes delivering the intended benefits or creating additional pressure?

The answers can help leaders distinguish between resistance to change and legitimate concerns about how change is being managed.

Turning employee feedback into meaningful change

Across higher education, institutions are already demonstrating how employee listening can strengthen communication, trust and the experience of organisational change.

At the Royal Northern College of Music, employee listening and visible action have supported measurable progress. Perceptions of change management improved by ten percentage points over two years, supported by transparent communication, local action planning and employee involvement.

Edinburgh Napier University has embedded continuous listening into its people strategy, using pulse surveys, local action plans and regular communication to maintain momentum. Belief that action would follow employee feedback increased by eight percentage points between 2022 and 2024.

At Exeter College, Oxford, improvements in communication, leadership visibility and employee involvement helped strengthen trust. Initiatives included regular all-staff meetings, greater staff representation and opportunities to discuss proposed changes before decisions were finalised.

Together, these examples reinforce an important principle: successful change depends not only on what leaders decide, but on how employees are informed, involved and supported throughout the process.

How HR teams can make change more sustainable

For university HR teams, there are five practical priorities.

  1. Understand the cumulative impact. Consider how multiple restructures, initiatives and new systems affect employees collectively, rather than evaluating each change in isolation.
  2. Involve employees early. Give colleagues meaningful opportunities to influence implementation, identify potential problems and contribute practical solutions.
  3. Protect capacity. Review workload, resources and competing priorities whenever responsibilities or processes change.
  4. Equip managers. Provide clear information, realistic expectations and the support managers need to guide their teams through uncertainty.
  5. Listen throughout the process. Use employee feedback to understand whether changes are manageable and delivering improvements, then communicate what is being done in response.

Sustainable change starts with listening

Universities cannot avoid change, and difficult decisions will sometimes be necessary.

But there is a difference between asking employees to adapt and expecting them to absorb continuous pressure without sufficient support.

For HR teams, the opportunity is to make employee experience a central consideration in how change is planned, communicated and delivered.

Successful transformation should not be measured only by what an institution changes, but by whether its people have the capacity, confidence and support to move forward with it.



People Insight

Jane Tidswell, HE Director

Jane.tidswell@peopleinsight.co.uk




Read more



This site uses cookies and other tracking technologies to assist with navigation and your ability to provide feedback, analyse your use of the site and services and assist with our member communication efforts. Privacy Policy. Accept cookies Cookie Settings